The Myths About Whiskey

By Craig Ellis
Author Bio: Craig's love for all things whiskey began when he visited his first distillery, Talisker in 2006. During his free time, he likes to visit distilleries around the globe, planning his travel around these locations. Craig created The Pot Still in 2016 when he first started to collect rare and unusual whiskeys. His whiskey collection has grown and grown since. Craig writes and reviews independently and is not commissioned by any brand or distillery. Craig's views and opinions are his own.
The Myths About Whiskey - The Pot Still Whiskey

It’s challenging enough to try to pick a whiskey that you like, while trying to scan the shelves of off-licences and supermarkets. Then you click on another Instagram Ad that you've been targeted by for searching a Single Malt whiskey. Let’s dispel the common myths about whiskey that you’ve spent your entire life believing.

Colour indicates age

The colour of a Whiskey does not give a definite indication of its age.

Whiskey Colouring Coded - colouring used in Whiskey

New make spirit is produced from the stills as a perfectly clear liquid, which begs the question, where does the colour of whiskey come from? Whiskey is mostly matured in oak casks, therefore the size and shape of the cask will effect the area of whisky that  interact with it. The condition of the cask, virgin, toasted, charred, remainders of previous liquids in the cask, how many times it has been used or re-used and finally the length of maturation will all play a part in determining colour. Other factors include but not limited to; location, climate conditions, type of wood, surrounding air pressure, humidity, etc. 

Whiskey gets colour from the barrel only

There's a reason why the statements ‘No added Colour’ or ‘Natural Colour’ is on a whiskey bottle as it suggests that the colour has no additives such as the addition of spirit caramel. Spirit Caramel additive also known as E150a is a food colouring made by heating of sugars without any other additive or preservatives. It has long been used in the whiskey industry to provide a uniform colouring of a natural product that might vary in colour due to cask maturation.

E150a Caramel Colouring use in Whiskey

This colouring is mainly used in Blends, Bulk vats or married whiskeys where hundreds of casks are going into the mixture to provide a consistent flavour. Each batch might taste the same, but the colour might not. Therefore, to ensure consumers aren't wary of bottles being drastically different colours, E150a is added. This has no effect on the taste and only requires a tiny amount to colour a single bottle or even a whole batch of whiskey.

By tradition and in some parts Regulations are in place so that nothing may be added to single malt scotch whisky, for example, a reasonably pure product, without threatening its status. With the exception of spirit caramel or in more recent legislation specifically E150a. Differing legislations apply around the world however, as do bottling requirements. For reference, bottles of whisky exported for sale in Germany or Denmark must have the use of colouring declared upon the label to meet legislation.

If it states 12 Year Old, it means only 12 Year Old 

Irish whiskey must be matured for a minimum of three years. If a bottle of Irish whiskey shows an age statement, e.g. "12 Years Old", that means that the youngest whiskey in the bottle is at least 12 years old. 

Age Statement WHiskey or Non-Age Statement Whiskey - The Pot Still

Irish whiskey is bottled at a variety of ages, from 3 years to 45 years. Grain whiskey is most often used between 3 and 5 years old in blended whiskey brands. Malt whiskey is used in blends from any age over 3 years old, but typically would be between 5 and 10 years old as malt matures more slowly than grain. For consumers still today, age statement is the biggest factor in buying decisions.

The Established year of all Whiskey brands are true

Incorrect. Some whiskey brands have been closed and relaunched over time under the old brand names, branding, locations, logos, etc. The famine, British rule, Economic climates, depressions, recessions, are to name a few reasons why great whiskey brands have opened and closed over time. The resurrection of these brands have been brought back by the likes of Pernod Ricard and Diageo, to bring back these old mashbills and whiskeys that have been long lost. However, the old establishment dates are still a part of their marketing. 

Bushmills 1608 or 1784

Also, here's a little history lesson: Bushmills' company itself didn’t come into existence until 1784, however, as you can see on their bottle, 1608 was the date that King James VI/I gave a licence to distil to the contemporary landowner. 1608 or 1784, we are still talking about a long legacy of distilling and whiskey making history.

Older whiskey tastes better

Taste is very subjective. Older whiskey definitely tastes different, but different isn’t always better, and what you consider better, I might not. That's the beauty of tastebuds and differences of opinion.

For example, a favourite whiskey brand of mine makes a whiskey that is aged 12 years, and one aged 21 years. I happen to love both of these expressions, nearly equally, but not equal. For me the younger 12 year whiskey edges out ahead of its' older sibling, but they’re rather different and I like them both for different reasons.

Older Whiskey tastes better than younger whiskey - The Pot Still

As in one of the previous myths, a whiskey is a blend of several different barrels, and the age you see listed on the bottle is simply the age of the youngest whiskey mixed in the blend. There could be older stuff in there, even much older stuff, used to create the overall flavour and balance they’re hoping to achieve. This is true even of “single malt” whisky, which simply means all the whiskeys in the final blend came from the same distillery. 

Age does impart certain qualities, it’s true, but whatever is on the label is just what the label says. What you taste is what matters. Are those age-imparted qualities benefiting the whiskey or not? They might, they might not!

Other Fun Facts About Whiskey (Uisce Beatha)

  • Single malt whiskey is whiskey from a single distillery made from a mash that uses one particular malted grain. Unless described “single-cask” it contains whiskey from many casks and different years. Typically, single malts bear the name of the distillery, an age statement, and some indication of special treatments such as maturation in a port wine cask.
  • Blended malt whiskey is a mixture of single malt whiskies from different distilleries. If labeled “pure malt” or “malt” it’s usually a blended malt whisky.
  • Blended whiskey is made from a mixture of different types of whiskey. A blend may contain whiskey from many distilleries which allows the blender to produce a flavour consistent with their brand. Most Scotch, Irish and Canadian whiskey is sold as part of a blend, even when the spirits are the product of one distillery.  
  • Single cask (also referred to as single barrel) whiskies are bottled from an individual cask, and often the bottles are labeled with specific barrel and bottle numbers. The taste of these whiskies may vary from cask to cask within a brand.
  • The age of Whiskey is determined by the youngest whisky used to produce that product. So if you have an 4-year-old Bourbon it means that if it’s a blend the youngest Bourbon in that bottle is 4 years old.
  • Weather affects the taste. Rickhouses aren’t climate controlled, so the barrels up top taste different than the ones below.
  • In WW2 distilleries were used to manufacture penicillin and it took until the 1980s for the industry to recover
  • The Scots chilled their whisky by grabbing small stones from the cold rivers and placing them in their whisky. Hence whisky stones.
  • The proceeds from Bhutan’s K5 Himalayan Whiskey helps to pay army pensions, provide loans, and finance scholarships for this small nation
  • The “Angels Share” is the amount of whiskey that evaporates every year it’s in the barrel. It can equate to about 2-15% a year based on climates. 
  • Tabasco Sauce is aged in old Jack Daniels Whiskey barrels
  • Whiskey can withstand extreme cold temperatures. Polar explorers carried whiskey on their journey to the South Pole and it remained liquid even at -30 degrees Celsius.

Tags: Whiskey, Whiskey Tasting

    The Pot Still

    Founded by Craig Ellis to educate the world on all whiskey types. Follow The Pot Still for reviews, virtual whiskey tastings, and all the latest whiskey news.

    • New to Whiskey? - World Whiskey Intro
    • Pot Still Whiskeys - Irish made
    • Scotch Whiskey - A fan of smoke
    • Japanese Whiskey - Blended taste

    Posts by Tag

    See all

    Recent Posts

    Subscribe to our Blog!

    Subscribe to our Email Subscription

    Sign up to The Pot Still Newsletter and we'll email you the latest blog posts to keep you up to date with all things Whiskey, especially Irish Whiskey.